Mahakumbh- Will it be rinse-and-repeat?
Mahakumbh: Will it be rinse-and-repeat?
![]() |
Some celebrities during the Kumbh |
You know how I have taken my habit and skill of worrying to such a level that whenever an award for worrying is instituted, my claim as the first and unanimous recipient stays uncontested.
The latest reason – a Kumbh returnee, soaked in
piety, in a sharp voice not bothering to hide his disdain, questioned me how I
qualify as a practicing Hindu even though I did not take the proverbial ‘holy
dip’ in the Sangam in spite of living just a few hours from the sacred site.
No, somehow, it did not trigger worry about my
being a Hindu because all of us have our own system of belief.
Bathing or dubki (taking a dip) too, is
a matter of belief and thus, does not give anyone the right to question. The
good thing is that followers of every religion have some such notion so nobody should
be stupid enough to raise eyebrows at anyone else.
My stomach is in knots- the official numbers
say nearly 56 crore visitors not only from India but from other countries too, cleansed
their sins in the holy river’s waters.
I am not concerned how they came up with such
exact numbers, or how more than one third of India’s population descended on the small city not
exactly equipped for this unique social distancing experiment, not even whether
the water is clean.
I have a different heap of worries e.g., has anyone wondered about the sociological changes that might take place following the Kumbh?
Will the sin and crime rate go up because more
than one third of our population has washed off their old sins? Does it give
the mischievous dark characters a chance to rinse and repeat?
Will the number of holy men and women not
merely in our country, but other countries too, go up staggeringly after people
have migrated to the ‘sin-free’ list?
We believers live in this constant effort of
protecting ourselves from not doing anything which results in paap lagega
(earns us sin).
Did the people who went out of curiosity or as
tourists, to witness the event or to take selfies, also earn punya?
In the tragedies occurring during such sacred
events who receives negative marking -politicians, officials, victims? What is
the status of the families who lost their dear ones?
Did not even a single soul accidently take jal-samadhi (immersion/burial in water/river) in
the Ganga during the six-week event?
Are we Indians procreating so fast that our
infrastructure is always insufficient?
I am going light-headed thinking about economy
vs morality.
The airlines earned whopping sums in
price-surge following the crazy jump in demand. Will this be counted as paap?
The railways did not jack up ticket prices,
remember India is a welfare state and railways does not work as a
profit-earning department, but who bears the weight of the ‘sin’ for tragedy?
![]() |
This is another level of entrepreneurship! |
Was the act of small-time sellers of wares making
money from the pilgrims during this time of latter’s necessity, immoral?
Were the boat-owners who generally got a measly
Rs 500 for a trip, but now agreed only after being handed out Rs 20,000 for the
same, wise entrepreneurs or low-level sinners?
Or the hoteliers who promised five-star luxury for
staggering tariff, and sometimes did not provide even hot water?
Did every person who turn someone into a
celebrity whether for the colour of the latter’s eyes or the way they flicked
their hair after the dip, earn some virtue brownie point?
And have the doctors/hospital authorities who
tended to the injured following the stampede earned punya? Their
contribution shall forever remain unmatched for not letting the casualty toll
creep up by even one beyond the official figures announced.
Are the efforts of host city students,
office-goers, shop-keepers, workers who struggled among the mammoth crowds to
reach their own destination to do what their day demanded, paap or punya?
How does God’s paap-punya balance sheet work?
Does He have some Godly intelligence to counter the artificial kind being used
by humans or merely uses calculus/algebra/geometry/trigonometry/statistics to
cancel out sins against this bathing?
What kind of marking system does He use for
those who took the dubki more than once? Or for the officials posted at the venue, in and around the
city to ensure the event went off otherwise uneventfully?
Should we be thankful to the genius who
calculated that this happens only once in 144 years?
Prayagraj residents like Mani’s cousin Atul bhaiyya
(brother) and Padma bhabhi (sister in law) and several thousand such
unsung event managers of this spiritual extravaganza, have received, hosted,
fed, taken to the safest spots, arranged for the holy dip, showed around the
glitzy stalls, brought them back from the venue, dropped off, - relatives,
friends, relatives’ relatives, friends’ friends, relatives’ friends or friends’
relatives, in the last month and a half. Is it near-Everest level of mehman-nawazi
/atithi-satkaar (hospitality) or of punya-kamayi (earning
virtues)?
Isn’t it good I did not go,
otherwise I would have committed the sin of pushing some of you to insomnia
following existential dread under the crushing weight of worries?
Now wait for another 12 or is it 144 years, in the hope of getting some answers. So long Allahabad, sorry Prayagraj! My salute to you!
-Anupama S Mani
Kumbh does not wash sins directly....but
ReplyDeleteYes
Coming to kumbh or visiting holy places and there
intreating with holy persons can polish your thought process.
This is the nursery class to attain salvation
This is the way we learn from eachother when we visit any holy place....
जो सवाल आपके हैं, उनमें से कुछ मेरे भी हैं:)
DeleteI dread going to a place where millions of ignorant are flocking , perceiving the gains a sight or a dip could bring.
ReplyDeleteJerusalem had so many stampedes in past , just few hundred years back. Mecca also has an equal score. So we can't be left behind.
Well said ma'am. 👌 Mrs.Narasimhulu
ReplyDeleteRaising pertinent questions and concerns on Kumbh is also kind of punya .. very aptly asked questions with beautiful testimonial review of the Maha-event 👍👍
ReplyDeleteIt is belief of an individual that HOIi Dip at the confluence of three rivers brings pious thoughts and wash away sins, done,knowingly or unknowingly. Every religion has some kind of such rituals but we get critical only for Hindus as we have been taught left idealogy who appreciated Mughals hence named major roads/ streets in the name of Mughal rulers.
ReplyDeleteYes, I agree with you.
DeleteThe biggest problem is with those religions, where it's followers start owning it like there own baby. They shall defend it's practices or preachings, as they would do for their own son.
DeleteSuch religions pose greatest threat to free thought and mankind.
Some religions should go through reforms in this changed world.
Once in 144 Years Sir
ReplyDelete